Skip to content

ConceptsStructure

The Change Gap Model

Definition

The Change Gap Model distinguishes four outcome positions to show how the possibilities available to a change become progressively constrained and what is ultimately realized.

Source
Concept paper, version 1.0, section 4
Canonical
https://www.intent-integrity.com/change-gap-model

In plain terms

The Change Gap Model is a way of reasoning about where the potential of a change may be lost or left unrealized. Establishing intent constrains the possibilities available in response to the change need, choosing a direction constrains them further, and execution produces a realized state within what remains possible. The model names the potential lost or left unrealized at each step, so that a disappointing outcome can be examined for where it arose rather than attributed to execution alone.

How it works

When a change need is taken up for deliberate consideration, different responses could lead to different organizational states and combinations of outcomes. Some of these outcome possibilities would be stronger than others, although neither the full range of possibilities nor how they should ultimately be judged can be known perfectly.

The model distinguishes four outcome positions. The change potential is the strongest outcome position reasonably achievable in response to the change need. The intent potential is the strongest reasonably achievable within the established intent. The direction potential is the strongest reasonably achievable within the chosen direction. The realized outcome position is what the realized state actually produced.

Establishing intent constrains the possibilities available in response to the change need, and choosing a direction constrains them further. Intent potential cannot exceed change potential, and direction potential cannot exceed intent potential. Execution produces a realized state and its outcomes within what remains possible through the chosen direction.

The distances between these positions are the gaps. The intent gap is the potential lost in establishing the intent. The direction gap is the potential lost in choosing a direction. The execution gap is the potential left unrealized through execution that was available through the chosen direction. Together they span the change gap.

The three potential positions are not directly observable. Potential is counterfactual: what could reasonably be achieved if the relevant choices and judgments were made as well as circumstances allow, not what the organization expects to achieve or has identified as desirable. The model does not require the organization to identify the potential positions, and the gaps cannot be calculated directly. Its purpose is to distinguish where choices may rule out stronger outcome possibilities and where execution may leave available potential unrealized. Practices that strengthen reasoning across intent, direction, and execution can increase the likelihood of preserving and realizing more potential without requiring those positions to be identified or measured.

Potential lost upstream cannot be recovered downstream unless the reasoning that constrained it is reconsidered. Strong execution can realize the potential available through the chosen direction, but it cannot restore stronger possibilities already ruled out by intent or direction.

The three gaps point to different sources of potential loss or non-realization. Addressing the intent gap requires stronger reasoning about what should be pursued and why. Addressing the direction gap requires stronger reasoning about how the established intent should be pursued. Addressing the execution gap requires effective realization of the chosen direction and sound, connected reasoning as execution unfolds.

Change Gap Model with the change gap highlightedThe change gap is highlighted: the potential lost or left unrealized between change potential and the realized outcome position. The intent, direction, and execution gaps lie between successive outcome positions and together span the change gap. The positions and distances are conceptual and illustrative rather than measurable.Change potentialIntent potentialDirection potentialRealized outcome positionIntent gapDirection gapExecution gapChange gap
Figure 3. The Change Gap Model. The change gap is highlighted: the potential lost or left unrealized between change potential and the realized outcome position. The intent, direction, and execution gaps lie between successive outcome positions and together span the change gap. The positions and distances are conceptual and illustrative rather than measurable.

Where it sits

The change gap decomposes into three parts that need different responses. The intent gap is the potential lost in establishing intent. The direction gap is the potential lost in choosing a direction. The execution gap is the potential left unrealized through execution. Potential lost upstream cannot be recovered downstream unless the reasoning that constrained it is reconsidered.

Terms defined here

Concepts that belong to this page rather than to a page of their own. Each has a stable anchor.

Outcome position

Definition

An outcome position represents the overall combination of relevant outcomes, considered in light of the values, interests, constraints, and trade-offs through which they should be judged.

The relevant outcomes of a change considered together, in light of the values, interests, constraints, and trade-offs through which they should be judged. It is multidimensional rather than a single outcome or measurable quantity. Relevant outcomes are not limited to those recognized or intended by the organization; an organizational state may also produce outcomes that are overlooked, misunderstood, unintended, or unobserved.

Potential

Definition

Potential represents a conceptual limit: the strongest outcome position that remains reasonably achievable within the possibilities still open to the change.

Potential is counterfactual rather than something the organization can directly identify or determine. It represents what could reasonably be achieved if the relevant choices and judgments were made as well as circumstances allow. It is not the same as what the organization expects to achieve or has currently identified as desirable. Its role in the model is to provide a reference for reasoning about how subsequent choices constrain what remains achievable.

Change potential

Definition

The change potential is the strongest outcome position reasonably achievable in response to the change need.

The strongest outcome position reasonably achievable in response to the change need, before intent has been established. It is the widest of the four positions.

Intent potential

Definition

The intent potential is the strongest outcome position reasonably achievable within the established intent.

The strongest outcome position reasonably achievable within the established intent. It cannot exceed the change potential, because establishing intent constrains the possibilities available in response to the change need.

Direction potential

Definition

The direction potential is the strongest outcome position reasonably achievable within the chosen direction.

The strongest outcome position reasonably achievable within the chosen direction. It cannot exceed the intent potential, because choosing a direction constrains the possibilities further. Because it is counterfactual, it cannot be observed directly; well-founded and sufficiently complete outcome targets can provide a practical reference point for reasoning about it.

Realized outcome position

Definition

The realized outcome position is the outcome position actually produced by the realized state that results from execution of the chosen direction.

The outcome position actually produced by the realized state that results from execution of the chosen direction. Outcome results provide evidence about it and, when they adequately capture the relevant outcomes, a practical approximation of it.

Change gap

Definition

The change gap is the potential lost or left unrealized between change potential and the realized outcome position.

The potential lost or left unrealized between change potential and the realized outcome position. It spans the intent gap, the direction gap, and the execution gap.

Each relationship is stated as a claim, so it can be checked against the definitions it connects.

Referenced by

Cite this page

Rozema, Lars. “The Change Gap Model.” Intent Integrity. https://www.intent-integrity.com/change-gap-model. n.d.

“n.d.” marks that this is a living page without a publication date; add an access date if your citation style requires one. To cite the framework itself, cite the concept paper.