ConceptsThe Intent LoopConcept
Intent tracing
Definition
Intent tracing is the practice of maintaining continuity between the reasoning behind intent and direction and the course of execution, so that significant divergence and emerging evidence can be understood in relation to that reasoning and earlier reasoning can be reconsidered when needed.
In plain terms
Intent tracing keeps the reasoning behind intent and direction connected to the course of execution, so that significant divergence and emerging evidence can be understood in relation to that reasoning, and earlier reasoning can be reconsidered when needed. It is the practice that reduces the expected execution gap arising from lost continuity.
How it works
Execution inevitably brings situations that were not fully anticipated when the direction was established. Many can be addressed within the established direction, while others may significantly affect the target state or approach, or challenge the reasoning behind the intent. Intent tracing maintains the continuity needed to distinguish between them.
Reasoning continuity can be lost when the course of execution diverges from the chosen direction without the significance of that divergence being recognized, or when emerging evidence that bears on the reasoning behind the direction or intent is not connected back to it. Where divergence or emerging evidence is significant, the relevant reasoning can be reconsidered as far upstream as needed. Reconsideration may confirm what was already established or lead to a revision of direction or intent.
Intent tracing concerns more than traceability. Whether needs, requirements, designs, and delivered components can be traced to one another is a separate question. Intent tracing keeps visible the reasoning that gives those elements significance: why the intended outcomes are being pursued, the assumptions and expected relationships behind the chosen direction, and how the course of execution relates to that reasoning. A requirement may remain traceable to its source even when the reasoning that made it important has changed or no longer holds.
Intent tracing should be proportionate to the change. Continuity needs to be strongest where divergence or emerging evidence could materially affect the reasoning behind the direction or intent. How much reasoning needs to be retained and made accessible depends on the scale, uncertainty, and stakes of the change. The specific mechanism is secondary, provided the relevant reasoning remains sufficiently available and connected.
Intent tracing reduces the expected execution gap arising from lost continuity. It does not address the part of the execution gap that arises from realizing the chosen direction poorly or incompletely, which is not itself a matter of intent integrity.
Where it sits
Intent tracing is the practice of the Execution function. It reduces the expected execution gap from lost continuity, not the whole of it.
Related concepts
Each relationship is stated as a claim, so it can be checked against the definitions it connects.
- Intent tracing is the practice for the Execution function of the Intent Loop.
- It addresses lost reasoning continuity and reduces the expected execution gap arising from that cause, not the whole of it.
- Silent drift is one form of the lost continuity it guards against.
- It maintains continuity, one of the two components of intent integrity, between the reasoning behind intent and direction and the course of execution.
Referenced by
Cite this page
Rozema, Lars. “Intent tracing.” Intent Integrity. https://www.intent-integrity.com/intent-tracing. n.d.
“n.d.” marks that this is a living page without a publication date; add an access date if your citation style requires one. To cite the framework itself, cite the concept paper.