Skip to content

ConceptsThe Change Gap ModelConcept

Direction gap

Definition

The direction gap is the potential lost in choosing a direction.

Source
Concept paper, version 1.0, section 4
Canonical
https://www.intent-integrity.com/direction-gap

In plain terms

The direction gap is the potential lost in choosing how to pursue an established intent. Several target states and approaches could pursue the same intent, and some would achieve more than others. Where the strongest outcome position reasonably achievable within the chosen direction is weaker than what could reasonably have been achieved within the established intent, the difference is lost at the point of choosing, and execution cannot recover it.

How it works

A direction rests on expectations that the approach will realize the target state and that the target state will produce the intended outcomes. Both are expectations about cause and effect, formed under uncertainty.

A direction gap may reflect weak evidence, untested assumptions, inadequate consideration of alternatives, poorly understood relationships between the chosen approach, target state, and intended outcomes, or insufficiently examined trade-offs.

Poorly founded reasoning when choosing direction increases the expected potential loss, but does not by itself establish that a direction gap exists. The gap is a difference between two potential positions, both of which are counterfactual. Outcome targets provide a practical reference point for reasoning about direction potential and, where the intended outcomes adequately represent the relevant outcome dimensions and the targets reflect sound judgments about what the chosen direction could reasonably achieve, may approximate it. They are not equivalent to it, and because both positions are counterfactual, the direction gap cannot be indicated through a direct comparison of observable references in the same way as the execution gap.

Even when the chosen direction is realized as intended, the resulting outcomes may differ from what was expected, reveal important unintended effects, or prove less valuable than assumed. Differences between outcome targets and results should therefore be interpreted rather than attributed automatically to execution; they may reflect assumptions about how the target state would produce outcomes.

Addressing the direction gap requires stronger reasoning about how the established intent should be pursued. Potential lost in choosing direction cannot be recovered through execution unless the direction and the reasoning behind it are reconsidered.

Change Gap Model with the direction gap highlightedThe direction gap is highlighted: the potential lost in choosing a direction. The intent, direction, and execution gaps lie between successive outcome positions and together span the change gap. The positions and distances are conceptual and illustrative rather than measurable.Change potentialIntent potentialDirection potentialRealized outcome positionIntent gapDirection gapExecution gapChange gap
Figure 3. The Change Gap Model. The direction gap is highlighted: the potential lost in choosing a direction. The intent, direction, and execution gaps lie between successive outcome positions and together span the change gap. The positions and distances are conceptual and illustrative rather than measurable.

Direction quality is the practice that reduces the expected direction gap.

Each relationship is stated as a claim, so it can be checked against the definitions it connects.

Referenced by

Cite this page

Rozema, Lars. “Direction gap.” Intent Integrity. https://www.intent-integrity.com/direction-gap. n.d.

“n.d.” marks that this is a living page without a publication date; add an access date if your citation style requires one. To cite the framework itself, cite the concept paper.