Skip to content

ConceptsThe Intent LoopConcept

Direction quality

Definition

Direction quality concerns the alternatives, evidence, assumptions, expected causal relationships, uncertainties, and trade-offs considered when choosing the target state and approach through which to pursue the established intent.

Source
Concept paper, version 1.0, section 5
Canonical
https://www.intent-integrity.com/direction-quality

In plain terms

Direction quality concerns how well an organization reasons its way to a target state and an approach for reaching it, given the intent it has established: the alternatives, evidence, assumptions, expected causal relationships, uncertainties, and trade-offs it considers when choosing. It is the practice that reduces the expected direction gap.

How it works

Choosing a direction requires reasoning from an understanding of the current state to what target state the organization should aim to create, how it proposes to move toward that target state, why the chosen approach is expected to succeed, and why the target state is expected to produce the intended outcomes. That reasoning depends on evidence and assumptions about cause and effect, feasibility, behavior, context, adoption, and other conditions that influence whether the approach will work and how the target state will operate.

Direction quality draws on decision quality as a foundation for well-founded reasoning and applies its principles to one choice: how the established intent should be pursued. Decision quality includes attention to an appropriate frame, creative and doable alternatives, relevant and reliable information, clear values and trade-offs, sound reasoning, and commitment to action.

The practice does not identify the strongest reasonably achievable outcome position, nor can it guarantee that the chosen direction preserves all of the potential available within the established intent. Its purpose is to strengthen the reasoning through which direction is established. Stronger reasoning should improve the likelihood of choices that preserve more of what remains reasonably achievable, so direction quality reduces the expected potential loss in choosing direction.

One pattern that motivated the framework was analysis beginning after a direction had already been set, or after an early idea had gained momentum. By that point, work often focuses on what is needed to make the proposed direction succeed, with less attention to whether it is the right one to pursue.

The Intent Loop with direction highlightedA wide horizontal conceptual framework titled The Intent Loop. A dotted boundary labelled Change capability contains four aligned functions: Intent with Intent quality, Direction with Direction quality, Execution with Intent tracing, and Validation with Outcome validation. Solid arrows connect these functions from left to right. Evolution, with Capability evolution, sits outside the boundary to the right and follows Validation. A curved solid arrow leads from Evolution into the upper-right portion of the Change capability boundary. Three dashed arrows show feedback from Direction to Intent, Execution to Direction, and Validation to Execution when reconsideration is needed.CHANGE CAPABILITY1IntentIntent quality2DirectionDirection quality3ExecutionIntent tracing4ValidationOutcome validation5EvolutionCapability evolution
Figure 5. The Intent Loop. Direction is highlighted: the function that chooses what to change and the approach for changing it. The five functions and their associated practices are shown in sequence. Solid arrows indicate the primary flow through the functions, while dashed arrows indicate feedback to earlier functions when reconsideration is needed. Evolution acts on change capability, the organization's capacity to undertake deliberate change, rather than returning directly to an earlier function of the current change.

Where it sits

Direction quality is the practice of the Direction function.

Each relationship is stated as a claim, so it can be checked against the definitions it connects.

Referenced by

Cite this page

Rozema, Lars. “Direction quality.” Intent Integrity. https://www.intent-integrity.com/direction-quality. n.d.

“n.d.” marks that this is a living page without a publication date; add an access date if your citation style requires one. To cite the framework itself, cite the concept paper.