Skip to content

ConceptsThe Intent LoopFunction of the Intent Loop

Validation

Definition

Establish evidence about emerging and realized outcomes, compare it with expectations, and assess what it implies for the reasoning behind the change.

Source
Concept paper, version 1.0, section 5
Canonical
https://www.intent-integrity.com/intent-loop/validation
Position of the Validation function in the Intent Loop
Function4 of 5 in the Intent Loop
VulnerabilityAssumed success
PracticeOutcome validation

What it is

Validation establishes evidence about emerging and realized outcomes, compares it with expectations, and assesses what it implies for the reasoning behind the change. It does not correspond to one of the three fundamental elements: it uses evidence about outcomes to assess and reconsider the reasoning behind them.

In the loop

The Intent Loop with validation highlightedA wide horizontal conceptual framework titled The Intent Loop. A dotted boundary labelled Change capability contains four aligned functions: Intent with Intent quality, Direction with Direction quality, Execution with Intent tracing, and Validation with Outcome validation. Solid arrows connect these functions from left to right. Evolution, with Capability evolution, sits outside the boundary to the right and follows Validation. A curved solid arrow leads from Evolution into the upper-right portion of the Change capability boundary. Three dashed arrows show feedback from Direction to Intent, Execution to Direction, and Validation to Execution when reconsideration is needed.CHANGE CAPABILITY1IntentIntent quality2DirectionDirection quality3ExecutionIntent tracing4ValidationOutcome validation5EvolutionCapability evolution
Figure 5. The Intent Loop. Validation is highlighted: the function that establishes evidence about outcomes, compares it with expectations, and assesses what it implies. The five functions and their associated practices are shown in sequence. Solid arrows indicate the primary flow through the functions, while dashed arrows indicate feedback to earlier functions when reconsideration is needed. Evolution acts on change capability, the organization's capacity to undertake deliberate change, rather than returning directly to an earlier function of the current change.

Validation follows Execution in the loop, but it does not wait for execution to finish. It can begin once meaningful outcome evidence becomes available. As evidence accumulates, it may confirm earlier reasoning or indicate that execution, direction, or intent should be reconsidered.

Outcome results provide evidence about realized outcomes and can be compared with outcome targets, while relevant unintended outcomes and changes in context also need to be considered. Even when the chosen direction is realized as intended, the resulting outcomes may differ from what was expected, reveal important unintended effects, or prove less valuable than assumed.

Differences between outcome targets and results should be interpreted rather than attributed automatically to execution. They may reflect how the chosen direction was realized, assumptions about how the target state would produce outcomes, changes in context, expectations that were poorly founded, or judgments about value, priorities, and trade-offs that need to be reconsidered.

Validation may therefore call execution, direction, or intent into question, and reconsideration can extend as far upstream as the evidence warrants. Where outcomes emerge much later or cannot be measured or attributed reliably to a single change, validation may be delayed or more limited without negating the value of maintaining intent integrity.

Vulnerability

Assumed success: treating delivery, implementation, or target attainment as sufficient evidence that the change worked. Meeting the outcome targets provides evidence that the targeted outcomes were realized as expected, but does not establish that the targets reflected direction potential, that the intent was well founded, or that the chosen direction preserved the potential available within that intent.

Outcome validation is the practice that addresses it. It establishes whether outcomes align with expectations and provides evidence for reconsideration.

Guiding question

What outcomes are we seeing, how do they compare with what we expected, and what does that tell us about the reasoning behind the change?

Cite this page

Rozema, Lars. “Validation.” Intent Integrity. https://www.intent-integrity.com/intent-loop/validation. n.d.

“n.d.” marks that this is a living page without a publication date; add an access date if your citation style requires one. To cite the framework itself, cite the concept paper.